Breaking News:

Just In

Supreme Court spike High Court ruling on President Muluzi case


Malawi’s Chief Justice has faulted High Court Judge Justice McLean Kamwambe for referring a case of the former President Bakili Muluzi to the top most Court before making his determination.

Muluzi, and his co-accused Violet Whisky, wanted the Supreme Court to direct that the High Court, sitting as a constitutional court, should determine that the charges were politically motivated and, therefore, should be dismissed.

“This was a misdirection on the part of the Court. The Learned Judge was supposed to decide whether it is necessary or not necessary for the matter to be submitted to the Chief Justice for further consideration.

“For all these reasons, this matter is returned to the original Court for the Learned Judge to determine as he might consider appropriate,” Chief Justice Andrew Nyirenda said Thursday.

The retired Malawi President first appeared in Court in February 2009. He is being accused of stealing K1.7 billion donor money and was initially charged with 80 counts of allegedly siphoning aid cash into his private account.

Defense Lawyer Tamando Chokotho applied to have the matter referred for constitutional review, alleging that the whole trial perverts the Constitution in many respects.

In his ruling the Chief Justice observed that the bone of contention is that the proceedings against Muluzi were actuated entirely by malice and, therefore, an abuse of Court process.

Justice Nyirenda said Muluzi is of the view that the process resulted in violation of the Constitution because the former Attorney General and the former Director of the Anti-Corruption Bureau’s (ACB) conduct, in attempting to fabricate evidence against Muluzi, undermined his right to a fair trial under Section 42(2) (f) of the Constitution.

Muluzi also argued that former President Bingu wa Mutharika’s conduct in using criminal political reasons contravened his responsibility to defend and uphold the Constitution and to provide Executive leadership in the interest of national unity in accordance with the Constitution as provided for in Section 88 (1) of the Constitution.

THe Defence argue that Mutharika’s conduct in instructing the Director of ACB to arrest him for political reasons and the subsequent arrest and consent to prosecute by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) undermined the independence of the DPP under Section 101(2) of the Constitution.

“These provisions read together, raise three issues. The first and straightforward issue is the composition of the High Court when hearing a matter that has been determined to be within the province of the sections,” said Justice Nyirenda in the ruling.

The second issue he mentioned is the material determination of a matter as being within the ambit of the provisions while the third issue is the procedure that must be complied with to eventually place the matter before the constitutional panel of the High Court.

The Judge observed that Chokotho and ACB Deputy Director, Reyneck Matemba, agreed that the original Court must make a determination that the matter is one where the interpretation or application of the Constitution is necessary.

“In other [words] there must be a determination by the original Court about the necessity of the referral,” he said.
Matemba argued before the court that the application from Muluzi was premature.

“We, therefore, humbly request this court to refer the matter back to the original Court to decide whether or not it is necessary that this matter be referred to this honourable court for certification,” said Matemba.

He further argued that in the event that the original court is satisfied that the referral is necessary and then makes the referral, the Supreme Court will then have to decide whether or not the matter before the Court expressly and substantively relates to or concerns the interpretation or application of the provision of the Constitution, before granting certification.

Related Posts

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Saulos Chilima: A masqueraded Messiah or a devil not yet known?

    Frank Kamanga Historically, in the kingdom of the blind, the one-eyed is king. This is probably why -and it is a worldwide phenomenon- desperate peoples around the globe are hanging by the slenderest of threads, putting their hope and trust in figures that either present themselves, or are being portrayed as modern-age “Messiahs”, vowing to…

  • Mrs Mia inspires DPP senior officials

    In a leaked whatsapp conversation among DPP gurus the blue officials said they wish Mrs Abida Mia who has a hardworking spirit was in their team. The DPP officials which include; Ben Phiri, Ngeme Kalilani and Nicholas Dausi just to mention a few said Abida Mia is an insiration to all women in politics. One…

  • FLASH BACK: Kaliati and cadets strip Eastern Region Chief naked, dethrone him

    By Nyasa Times Published: June 6, 2011 Chief Mponda of Nsamala Village in Balaka district, who claim to have been paraded naked by Democratic Progressive Party DPP) Youth Cadets last month, has cried foul over the news that he has been stripped off his chieftaincy. Mponda was beaten up, rubbed down with buffalo beans (chitedze)…

  • DPP, UTM wrestle over corruption evidence

    Two of Malawi’s political parties; the United Transformation Party (UTM) and the Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) are pointing fingers at each other over corruption allegations. DPP’s Nicholas Dausi said that Chilima’s secrets will be revealed if he continues to talk ill about the DPP. “He has skeletons in his wardrobe, but he is busy talking…

  • Buleya Lule was electrocuted, assaulted

    Malawi’s Forensic Pathologist and Clinical Forensic Physician, Charles Dzamalala has released results of the medical investigation on the death of Buleya Lule, a suspect in the abduction of Dedza boy born with albinism. Buleya Lule died suddenly on Wednesday, 21st February 2019 while in Police custody after being arrested when he was being suspected to…

  • JB tells govt to speak out on Buleya

    The former President of the country, Joyce Banda has urged government to speak out on how a susppect who was accused of taking a role in the abduction of people living with albinism  died in Police custody. The former President said Malawians need answers on Buleyas death. “This man who died mysteriously in the hands…